This post spawns from the following reddit thread:
reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/29qfnm/
"It's 3 PM," she said.
I said, "You're crazy"
She said, "Get out of bed.
Why are you so lazy?
Why waste the day away?"
I said, "Because I'm tired."
--Wake Up Call, Relient K
I don't think that there's any argument that there are a lot of people who stay up late or sleep in that are lazy. Obviously there's a very high statistical probability that there is overlap between the groups. I won't argue against that. What I am arguing, though, is that there are lots of hardworking people who 'do their thing' at night and there are people who, unfairly, label them lazy and, unknowingly, discriminate against them.
I think the root cause of this (and many things) is the considerable generational gap on this issue, magnified by the Baby Boom. It's very easy to create a collective impression, share/spread it, and feel confident in it because it's popular. This means that when a Baby Boomer feels a certain way, the reasons they feel that way are probably shared by
almost a third of America. So suddenly, every third person agrees with you. And that third person is probably a successful one. And those two people might be an old fart or some young punk. Clearly you're right, right?
Once confirmation bias slips into the mix, the largest and most powerful single faction in our country- divided as they may be about gun control, health care, and gay marriage, are united on the things they grew up believing. They're also willing to ignore proof of the contrary. Whatever they learned as a group, whatever they suffered in common, whatever they saw as successful at one time is stuck that way, until the confirmation bias stops. One of those things they can't seem to shake is this premise that being asleep in daylight is a bad thing.
There are good reasons they would have learned not to do this. Fifty years ago the average boomer was 14 and looking to be successful for the first time, trying to figure out what that meant. Working at night was a non-starter. The biggest issue was that no one else was doing it. The people who would end up with money and power were the managers waking up at the crack of dawn to go to work. Jobs like construction, farming, and manufacturing required sunlight, and the real money was in service jobs, feeding, managing, or protecting those people. I don't have data on the rate of daylight dependent jobs or service jobs that depended on that group. The best I could find was data recording the
employment by sector for that time period. That has the numbers, so maybe I'll come back to it and make a pie chart. Even without that data, though, I don't think there's an argument. Some jobs depend on sunlight (construction, surveying), more jobs depend on people employed in jobs that depend on sunlight (food service, transportation), and very few jobs were even possible without rest of the labor force being awake (writers, researchers).
So, naturally, infrastructure did more for people in the day than in the night. Buses had last stops, government offices closed in the afternoon, and doctors went home at night. This was done with the reasonable expectation that there was simply less to do at night- that makes it prime time for sleeping. Even emergency services, like firefighters and nurses, who sleep at shift's end generally have less to do at night. Shops open 24/7 get obvious periods during which, admittedly, a lazy person could excel- the graveyard shift.
But something has been happening lately- very recently in fact. Today, 24/7 stores do not have graveyard shifts. They aren't as busy, but Wal-Mart workers, for example, need to be as attentive at 3am as they would be at 3pm. Stock traders who work in markets across the globe need to work and sleep in the timezone their clients are in, regardless of the Earth's position in the Sun's orbit. Some jobs
require the night- roadwork, guards, entertainment jobs. Plenty of jobs consider the time of day irrelevant and require night shifts to be filled- 24 hour food service and shops, IT. So there are more and more people walking around at 4am, looking for a bite to eat.
The other trend happening now (and for a long time, actually) is that jobs that actually require daylight are getting fewer and fewer. Factories are being run 24/7. Farming is being automated (no really, with robots and GPS and computers, Oh My!). So we, the working population, have to be open to working at night. Infrastructure has started to respond, and business were quick to catch on. The same reasons to provide service during banking hours are motivating businesses to provide service at night.
But not everyone has caught up.
Baby Boomers live in their own, confirmation bias supported, world. It's filled with the bankers, doctors, lawyers, business owners, judges, accountants, and government workers who all decided that 9-5 was right for them- and it was when they decided it. Today they have so much momentum that they are even almost right to a degree. Since they have the power and clout, it really is hard to be successful when they're asleep. Remember, we're talking about a third of the country here- one out of every three mouths to feed, people to transport, citizens to govern. Plus, everyone who has to fall in line; the students they teach, the secretaries they hire, people trying to make money off of them. Almost all of those people, though, could be working at night if they had business to do then.
That momentum can be a problem for people who aren't "with the program".
Discrimination is almost never an intent. Few people wake up and think "What's the most efficient way to be racist today?". So when I say that, for lack of a better term, day shift workers discriminate against night shift workers, I'm not trying to accuse anyone of thinking about ways to hurt people. I'm talking about people that can't see the effect of what they're doing- probably because they're asleep when it happens. Mostly, the discrimination comes in the form of closing up shop. That's a logically motivated decision, though, and one I won't admonish. No one opens a restaurant trying to satisfy some moral imperative to feed these people in this place at this time, so I won't argue that they should feed those people in that place at night. Especially because, without the coordination of their community, it would be a very bad business decision.
Some businesses, however, do have a moral imperative. Emergency services do work at night, but banks don't. And it has become impossible to function without a bank- many employers will only pay into an account and often times a credit or debit card is the only accepted payment at a given place. Banks should be staying open at night, or at least past 5, or at least open during the weekend. Not because it will net them more money, but because we depend on them just as much as we depend on medical, police, and firefighting services. Frankly, I'm pissed off that we don't have a government run bank. It's only logical and would give us power in the decisions it made.
Some discrimination I find hard to call discrimination. It's not even about inconveniencing people by mistake or ignorance- there's simply no time to satisfy everyone. A jackhammer outside your building is going to make it hard to sleep. It's not a bad thing to do it at a time when the majority of people are awake. But people who aren't following the nine to five clock are still the ones bearing the burden- everywhere. Maybe some day we'll figure out a way to fix that, but not today. Today too many people just don't care.
Finally, there's confrontational discrimination. People who won't do business with someone who keeps odd hours (see that, we even have linguistic discrimination- the hours are just different, nothing odd about them). People who require workers to be present at a particular time and place when
studies confirm that they do better work at their own home and own hours. People who judge their friends, families, and neighbors based on the hours they choose to sleep.
But pretty soon, the children of Baby Boomers are going to be picking up the mantle and finding the day workers less and less important to consider when deciding when to do what. And pretty soon, they'll be finding the concerns of the night shift worker every bit as important as his day shift counterpart. I really hope to see the complete disconnect from the sun we have fully realized. We already work in environmentally controlled and artificially lit spaces isolated from nature. There's no good reason to keep that day oriented momentum. We can end it.